General information, not legal or tax advice. Talk to an attorney or tax professional about your situation.
TL;DR
- There is no federal non-compete ban. The FTC's 2024 rule was set aside by a federal court and the FTC dropped its appeals in 2025, so state law decides whether an advisor's non-compete holds up.
- A handful of states, including California, Minnesota, North Dakota and Oklahoma, ban most employee non-competes. Others limit them by pay level. Florida made them easier to enforce for higher earners in 2025.
- Non-solicit clauses (which bar contacting former clients) are generally treated as a narrower restriction than non-compete clauses (which bar working in the industry or geography at all).
- The Broker Protocol covers a narrow set of acts for moves between firms that have both signed it. Its text does not mention non-competes, and it doesn't override every contract term.
- What matters most before signing: the geographic scope, the time period, the definition of "solicitation," which state's law governs, and whether both firms are Protocol signatories.
- A lawyer who handles advisor transitions, not a general business attorney, should review any contract with a restrictive covenant before you sign or before you resign.
What is a non-compete clause, really?
A non-compete clause is a contract term that restricts what an advisor can do after leaving a firm. It typically limits where the advisor can work, for how long, and sometimes bars working in the same industry at all within a defined radius.
Non-competes are often bundled with other restrictive covenants in an advisor's employment agreement or partnership agreement. Firms use different labels for related but distinct promises, and the differences matter a lot when a dispute happens:
- Non-compete: bars working for a competing firm, or in the same line of business, within a certain area for a set time.
- Non-solicit: bars actively reaching out to former clients or former colleagues to bring them to a new firm.
- Non-disclosure/confidentiality: bars using or sharing proprietary firm information, such as client lists or pricing models.
- Garden leave: requires an advisor to sit out for a period, often paid, before starting a new role.
An advisor might sign one document that contains all four. Reading the whole agreement, not just the section labeled "non-compete," is the only way to know what's actually being restricted.
Are non-compete clauses even enforceable for financial advisors?
It depends heavily on the state and on how the clause is written. There is no federal rule to fall back on. The FTC adopted a nationwide non-compete ban in 2024, a federal court in Texas set it aside, and in September 2025 the FTC voted to drop its appeals and accept that ruling. That leaves state law in charge.
State approaches vary widely. A handful of states, including California, Minnesota, North Dakota and Oklahoma, ban most employee non-competes. Another group, including Colorado, Illinois, Massachusetts, Virginia and Washington, limits them by pay level or type of worker. Most other states allow non-competes if the restriction is reasonable in scope, geography and duration and protects a legitimate business interest, such as client relationships or trade secrets, rather than simply blocking competition.
Florida, where many advisors live and work, went the other direction. Its CHOICE Act, passed in 2025, applies to employees earning more than twice the annual mean wage in the relevant Florida county. For those employees it allows non-competes of up to four years, creates a presumption that a covered agreement is enforceable, and provides for preliminary injunctions against violations. The Act also has formal requirements, including written notice of the right to talk to a lawyer and at least seven days to review the agreement, so whether a particular contract qualifies is a question for a Florida attorney.
States also differ on what a court does with a clause that goes too far. Some let a judge narrow an overly broad restriction and enforce the rest. Others strike the whole clause. As a hypothetical, a clause that bars an advisor from working anywhere in the country for five years might be cut down to a short radius for a year in one state and thrown out entirely in another. This is why the same contract language can hold up in one state and fail in another. An advisor evaluating a job offer, or deciding whether to challenge a clause after leaving, needs state-specific advice. General business attorneys who don't specialize in advisor transitions sometimes miss industry-specific nuances, like how the Broker Protocol interacts with a contract's non-solicit language.
What's the difference between a non-compete and a non-solicit, in practice?
A non-solicit is generally treated as a narrower restriction than a broad non-compete, because it protects a narrower interest: existing client relationships rather than an advisor's ability to work at all. Some state laws reflect the difference directly. Minnesota's non-compete ban, for example, does not cover non-solicitation agreements.
Courts in many states tend to view a non-solicit differently because it doesn't stop someone from earning a living in their field. It just limits who they can actively contact. A non-compete that blocks an advisor from working in wealth management anywhere nearby for two years is a much bigger restriction on livelihood, and that kind of clause usually draws closer scrutiny.
The practical difference shows up most in what an advisor can do on day one at a new firm. Under a non-solicit, an advisor generally can't call, email, or mail former clients to ask them to move accounts. But if a former client independently decides to follow the advisor and calls first, many non-solicit clauses treat that differently than active outreach. Clients also keep their own right to move: FINRA Rule 2140 bars member firms and their people from interfering with a customer's request to transfer a brokerage account when the customer's rep changes firms, unless the account is subject to a lien or other bona fide claim. The line between "soliciting" and "informing" is a frequent point of dispute, which is exactly why the wording of the clause matters.
What is the Broker Protocol, and does it cancel out a non-compete?
The Broker Protocol is a voluntary agreement among firms, first signed in 2004, that lets a departing advisor take five pieces of client information (name, address, phone number, email address and account title) for clients they serviced, when moving between two firms that have both signed it. Under its terms, a departing advisor and new firm that follow it would have no monetary or other liability to the old firm for taking that information or for soliciting those clients after the advisor joins the new firm.
The Protocol does not erase every restrictive covenant. It covers a specific, narrow set of acts, and only if the advisor follows its procedure: resign in writing to local branch management, include a copy of the client information being taken (the list given to the branch also includes account numbers, which the advisor does not take), and wait until after joining the new firm before soliciting. Before resignation, a firm can still enforce whatever contract, statutory or common law limits exist on soliciting customers.
Several things the Protocol does not cover:
- Moves where either the old firm or the new firm isn't a Protocol signatory.
- Taking any documents or information beyond the five permitted fields, such as financial plans, account statements or proprietary firm materials.
- Non-compete language that restricts where an advisor can work. The Protocol text does not mention non-competes at all.
- Garden leave provisions, which the Protocol text also does not address.
- So-called "raiding" claims, which the old firm keeps the right to bring.
An advisor moving from one Protocol firm to another, following the procedure, is in a much stronger position on client information and solicitation than one who isn't, but membership does not rule out litigation entirely. Merrill Lynch, for example, sued two departing advisors in 2018 who had moved to another Protocol firm. An advisor moving to or from a non-signatory firm should not assume Protocol-style protections apply. That includes advisors going independent: an RIA can join the Protocol, and some do, but a newly formed RIA is only covered if it has signed. For advisors weighing that independent path, a clear step-by-step sequence for going independent is worth reviewing well before resignation, since the order of operations affects legal exposure.
What should an advisor actually check before signing?
Before signing any agreement with a restrictive covenant, an advisor should read for five specific things: scope, geography, duration, the definition of solicitation, and what happens to deferred compensation if they leave.
- Scope: Does the clause bar working in the industry at all, or just soliciting former clients? A total industry ban is far more aggressive than a client-contact restriction.
- Geography: Is the restricted area a specific radius, a state, or "anywhere the firm does business"? Broad or undefined geography is a red flag and is commonly one of the first things challenged.
- Duration: Is it six months, one year, two years? In states that allow non-competes, longer periods generally face more scrutiny, though Florida's CHOICE Act now allows up to four years for covered higher earners.
- Definition of solicitation: Does the clause count a client calling the advisor first as a violation? Some contracts define solicitation so broadly that almost any contact counts, which can be difficult to defend against later.
- Deferred compensation clawbacks: Forgivable loans, retention bonuses and deferred comp can be tied to staying, with the advisor repaying the balance or forfeiting unvested amounts if they leave. This isn't technically a non-compete, but it can function like one financially, and it deserves the same scrutiny.
It's also worth asking whether the firm is a Broker Protocol signatory today, and whether that status could change. Morgan Stanley, UBS and Citigroup all withdrew in 2017 and 2018. The Protocol lets a signatory withdraw at any time and only asks that it "endeavor" to give 10 days' written notice. The official signatory list is kept by J.S. Held and updated weekly, so it's worth checking at the time of resignation, not just at hire.
Can an advisor negotiate a non-compete before signing?
Often, yes, especially for advisors with an existing book of business or a strong production record. Firms recruiting an established advisor often have room to narrow scope, shorten duration, or clarify solicitation language, even if their standard template looks rigid.
Advisors sometimes assume a contract is take-it-or-leave-it because it's presented as standard paperwork. In practice, firms competing for a producing advisor are often willing to modify specific clauses, particularly geographic radius and the definition of what counts as solicitation. This is a normal part of offer negotiation, not an unusual request, and it's easier to negotiate before signing than to challenge after the fact.
Advisors evaluating a move between an RIA and a wirehouse should also weigh how restrictive covenants interact with pay structure, since a lower non-compete risk sometimes offsets a lower headline payout. A breakdown of what payout percentages actually hide covers how these tradeoffs show up in total compensation, not just the base number on an offer letter.
What happens if an advisor already signed a bad non-compete?
An advisor who already signed a broad or aggressive clause still has options, but the right move depends heavily on the state, the firm's Protocol status, and how the departure is handled. This is a situation where advance planning matters more than after-the-fact damage control.
An attorney experienced in advisor transitions can usually assess, before resignation, how a specific clause is likely to hold up if challenged, and can help structure the exit to reduce risk. That includes decisions like what to say in a resignation letter, what devices or files to avoid touching, and how to time the notice. For advisors preparing to leave a large wirehouse specifically, a pre-resignation planning guide walks through the practical sequence many advisors miss, and the broader question of how to move a book of business without a lawsuit covers the mechanics that apply across firms, not just one.
Firms considering how to recruit advisors who are wary of restrictive contracts also have a role here. Offering clearer, narrower language upfront, rather than a maximalist template, tends to reduce friction during recruiting conversations and can be a meaningful differentiator, particularly when competing for advisors who've already been burned by an overly broad clause elsewhere.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does a non-compete still apply if an advisor is fired rather than resigns?
It depends on the contract language and the state. Some agreements specify that restrictive covenants apply regardless of how employment ends, while others soften or waive the restriction if the advisor is terminated without cause. This clause should be checked specifically, since many advisors assume being let go automatically voids the non-compete, and that isn't always true.
Can a firm enforce a non-compete against an advisor who moves to a completely different type of firm, like an RIA instead of a wirehouse?
Sometimes, if the clause is written broadly enough to cover "the securities industry" or "financial services" rather than a specific type of firm. Advisors planning a move from a traditional brokerage into an independent or RIA model, including those starting an RIA from scratch, should have the exact wording reviewed before assuming a change in business model sidesteps the restriction.
Is a verbal promise that "we won't enforce it" worth anything?
Usually very little. Written terms usually control in a dispute, especially when the contract has an integration clause saying the document is the entire agreement, so a manager's or recruiter's verbal assurance is hard to rely on if the firm later decides to enforce the clause as written. Any change to a restrictive covenant should be in writing and signed.
Do non-compete rules differ for advisors working remotely or across state lines?
Yes, and this is an increasingly common gray area as more advisory work happens remotely. Which state's law applies can depend on where the advisor is physically based, where clients are located, and what the contract's choice-of-law clause says. Some states have weighed in directly: California says its ban applies regardless of where and when the contract was signed, and Florida's CHOICE Act applies to employees whose primary place of work is in Florida regardless of a choice-of-law clause. How courts sort out these conflicts is still unsettled. Firms building out remote advisor teams should expect this question to come up more often and should have contract language that anticipates it rather than defaulting to a single state's assumptions.
Does a shorter non-compete period always mean it's more enforceable?
Not automatically. Duration is one factor courts weigh alongside geography and scope, and the rules differ by state. Florida, for example, now allows non-competes of up to four years for covered higher earners. In the disputes we've seen discussed in industry and legal commentary, shorter, narrower clauses tend to face less pushback than long, broad ones, though outcomes still depend on the specific state and the specific facts of the departure.
Sources
- Federal Trade Commission Files to Accede to Vacatur of Non-Compete Clause Rule, Federal Trade Commission. Accessed .
- Noncompete Agreements: What's the Status of Laws Restricting Them Nationwide? (March 2026 Update), Katz Banks Kumin LLP. Accessed .
- Florida Doubles Down on Non-Competes as Florida CHOICE Act Becomes Law, Morrison & Foerster LLP. Accessed .
- 50 State Noncompete Chart, Beck Reed Riden LLP. Accessed .
- Protocol for Broker Recruiting, securitieslaw.com. Accessed .
- The Broker Protocol, J.S. Held. Accessed .
- Complying With The Broker Protocol When Changing Firms Or Going Independent, Kitces.com. Accessed .
- Broker Protocol Firms List 2026, Winthrop & Co.. Accessed .
- Broker Protocol Update: Merrill Wants to Have it Both Ways, Shustak Reynolds & Partners, P.C.. Accessed .
- FINRA Rule 2140: Interfering With the Transfer of Customer Accounts in the Context of Employment Disputes, FINRA. Accessed .